Skip to content
Updated How AI-exposed are the skills employers are hiring for? See the data →

From the employer's careers site First seen 25 Oct 2026 · Still live on 31 Oct 2026

Manager II, Customer Care Tax

Toast Remote senior full-time

Salary

$115,000-$184,000 USD per year

Apply on Toast

Description

As a Customer Care Tax Manager at Toast, you will actively manage a team of agents for the Payroll Tax campaign.

You are responsible for the productivity and well-being of the Customer Care Tax Team, improving customer experience through department-level KPIs and OKRs, and overseeing the customer journey for those experiencing Toast Payroll Tax issues.

Key responsibilities include:

  • Educating, managing, training, coaching, and mentoring a team of 10-12 Care Tax Experts
  • Evaluating employee performance, ensuring accountability, and monitoring customer outcomes and agent key performance indicators
  • Providing coaching and feedback to agents through the Quality Assurance process or one-on-one sessions
  • Training and developing team members on processes, technical troubleshooting, and new product knowledge
  • Maintaining open communication with agents and relaying concerns and ideas to others
  • Communicating and influencing new ideas for improvement with a solutions-oriented mindset
  • Assisting agents with challenging customer contacts and facilitating Supervisor Calls through escalations
  • Ensuring Service Level Agreements (SLA) for tax-related cases are met
  • Providing subject matter expertise related to payroll and tax filing
  • Providing Payroll analytics and reporting to management
  • Staying up-to-date with Federal, State, and Local regulatory changes and developing internal and external communications

Requirements:

  • 2+ years of experience in the Payroll/Tax field or closely related role
  • 3+ years of experience in performance managing and coaching as a people leader
  • 4+ years of experience in a role responsible for customer satisfaction and championing the customer experience
  • Demonstrated strong communication, interpersonal, and analytical skills
  • Experience working with escalated customers
  • Proficient with filing original and amended payroll tax returns
  • Experience working with tax authorities and understanding the tax notice/resolution process end-to-end
  • Solution-oriented with proven ability to drive results
  • Experience working for a Payroll Service Provider
  • Proficient in Microsoft Excel

Nice to haves:

  • Experience with MasterTax
  • FPC or CPP Certification

We offer a competitive compensation and benefits program, including:

  • Base salary range: $115,000-$184,000 USD (Zone A), $100,000-$160,000 USD (Zone B), $90,000-$144,000 USD (Zone C)
  • Cash compensation (overtime, bonus/commissions if eligible)
  • Equity
  • Benefits

Learn more about our benefits at https://careers.toasttab.com/toast-benefits.

Skills

Required

Nice to have

  • MasterTax
  • FPC or CPP Certification

Ready to apply?

You apply with the employer directly. Their original posting is here: https://job-boards.greenhouse.io/toast/jobs/8279381

Apply on Toast